WhisperJet wrote:Okay, you keep saying the 1-11 is more pocket than rocket.
Do we really need to discuss that? If so, I'll throw so-called "progress" into the pot:
Remember, they killed the Concorde, they ceased to produce the TU154 but they let the Dash8 survive.
See it that way and you got enuff puff to be back in business in a 1-11 2011 flight sim environment.
Nick
I am as big an advocate of the 1-11 as anyone, but the 1-11's performance was pretty appalling by modern standards. Once the temperature was above 20 degrees generally you started losing take-off weight rapidly. De-mineralised Water Injection restored the performance slightly but still didn't give you full weight. At the Start of the summer season, we used to ship 50kg barrels of De-min water in the hold to all the locations we were programmed to visit during the summer for stockpiling, these mainly being Spain, Italy, Greece, Malta, Portugal and North Africa, where temperatures would be considerably higher than 20. The First Officer would spend the turnround sweating over a wobble-pump to get the required 300-350 kgs into the aircraft's tank. Bear in mind that the improvement in performance had to be greater than the amount of water required or you had a net decrease in performance!
50% of our return flights from Athens would tech-stop at Brussels or Ostend for a comination of headwinds and being unable to lift max weight off Athens because of the temperature. Sometimes they didn't get that far and would lob into Munich or Milan.
One route was to Skiathos. Here there was no fuel available, so the planned route was Gatwick-Skiathos-Thessalonika-Gatwick. The idea was to arrive at Skiathos with enough fuel to get to Thessalonika. If you couldn't do that you went into Thessalonika on the way in and uplifted fuel to go to Skiathos and then Gatwick. One memorable hot summers day, the aircraft was weight limited out of Gatwick, stopped at Thessalonika on the way into Skiathos for fuel, because of the temperature at Skiathos they couldn't uplift enough fuel to get to Skiathos and back to Gatwick so stopped again at Thessalonika on the way back and then because of the temperature there, had to stop again at Munich, so the actual route was Gatwick-Thessalonika-Skiathos-Thessalonika-Munich-Gatwick!!
If BAC had stretched the aircraft into the 500srs sooner, it might have had more success against the DC-9-30 as Douglas stetched theirs first even though the -200 flew first. As to re-engining and the Romanians re-opening the production line, BAe were somewhat concerned about the effects a re-engined 1-11 would have on their 146 sales.
But after all that, the 1-11 was a wonderful aircraft. To quote one of our Captains who went on to fly the 737 with Air Europe, "The 737 is the better airliner, the 1-11 is the better aeroplane."
Nige