Page 1 of 2

My daughter, the plane spotter

Posted: 16 Aug 2021, 14:34
by Paul K
Katherine, my younger daughter, spotted this Ford Trimotor over her house in Michigan this past weekend. Apparently, the engine noise drew her outside - does anyone know if the prop tips go supersonic, like the Harvard ? The aircraft is giving flights from a nearby airport, probably KBEH. Not much detail to be seen at that distance, but it was nice of her to know I would be interested. :)

Image

Image

Re: My daughter, the plane spotter

Posted: 16 Aug 2021, 14:49
by TSR2
Now that's something you don't see every day. Great find Katherine :thumbsup:

Re: My daughter, the plane spotter

Posted: 16 Aug 2021, 16:08
by Tomliner
Well spotted Katherine. A flight in that would be a real experience :thumbsup: EricT

Re: My daughter, the plane spotter

Posted: 16 Aug 2021, 16:55
by Tako_Kichi
It was probably one of this pair that have been giving rides recently according to this website.

https://www.southbendtribune.com/story/ ... 510162001/

The Ford international headquarters are of course in Detroit, Michigan (along with GM and Chrysler) so the planes are not too far from their birthplace.
:)

Re: My daughter, the plane spotter

Posted: 16 Aug 2021, 21:27
by FlyTexas
You raised Katherine well, Paul. :lol: Any woman who'll go outside to watch an aircraft fly past is a friend of mine. :thumbsup:

Brian

Re: My daughter, the plane spotter

Posted: 17 Aug 2021, 04:13
by Airspeed
Good story, Paul.
Must have been a high speed exposure, all three props clearly shown.

Re: My daughter, the plane spotter

Posted: 17 Aug 2021, 13:59
by Nigel H-J
I do believe that former pilots of the Ford Trimotor had their careers ended prematurely due to the high level of noise from the engines. Would have been like sitting in an old small corrugated shed with three motorbikes outside with no silencers at full throttle!!

Regards
Nigel.

Re: My daughter, the plane spotter

Posted: 17 Aug 2021, 17:02
by Paul K
Thanks for all the very kind responses, chaps. I sent a link to Katherine, so she's had a look through them. :thumbsup:

Nigel H-J - A good while ago, one of the members of the A2A forum had a flight as co-pilot in a Tin Goose. Given its reputation, as you have mentioned, I asked him if was very noisy. He said that it wasn't anything excessive, which surprised me a little. Katherine said it was deafening as it went over. Maybe they've installed modern sound insulation inside.

Re: My daughter, the plane spotter

Posted: 17 Aug 2021, 19:33
by mgchristy
Your daughter has a good eye, Paul!
A good while ago, one of the members of the A2A forum had a flight as co-pilot in a Tin Goose. Given its reputation, as you have mentioned, I asked him if was very noisy. He said that it wasn't anything excessive, which surprised me a little. Katherine said it was deafening as it went over. Maybe they've installed modern sound insulation inside.
My father and I took a 15-20 minute ride on the EAA Ford Trimotor a few years back during a stopover at a local airfield. I concur with the A2A member's analysis. While it made a good racket from the outside, the interior noise wasn't nearly as bad as I was expecting, particularly once they throttled back after takeoff. Perhaps sound insulation, or perhaps just reduced power settings compared to what was used 'back in the day'. Granted, I was seated in the rear of the cabin....and I'd probably feel differently if I had to endure the noise on a multi-hour flight across the Alleghenies! :lol:

Not very high quality, but a small video before and during our ride to illustrate. Pardon my pitiful 'camera' work...
https://vimeo.com/170217650

Re: My daughter, the plane spotter

Posted: 17 Aug 2021, 21:57
by Paul K
mgchristy wrote:
17 Aug 2021, 19:33
Your daughter has a good eye, Paul!
A good while ago, one of the members of the A2A forum had a flight as co-pilot in a Tin Goose. Given its reputation, as you have mentioned, I asked him if was very noisy. He said that it wasn't anything excessive, which surprised me a little. Katherine said it was deafening as it went over. Maybe they've installed modern sound insulation inside.
My father and I took a 15-20 minute ride on the EAA Ford Trimotor a few years back during a stopover at a local airfield. I concur with the A2A member's analysis. While it made a good racket from the outside, the interior noise wasn't nearly as bad as I was expecting, particularly once they throttled back after takeoff. Perhaps sound insulation, or perhaps just reduced power settings compared to what was used 'back in the day'. Granted, I was seated in the rear of the cabin....and I'd probably feel differently if I had to endure the noise on a multi-hour flight across the Alleghenies! :lol:

Not very high quality, but a small video before and during our ride to illustrate. Pardon my pitiful 'camera' work...
https://vimeo.com/170217650

Mark, thanks very much. She also sent me a video of two V-22 Ospreys while she was living in New York earlier this year, asking what they were. ;)

Found the thread on the A2A forum, and it is the same aircraft you flew in ( NC8407). Some interior pics to see:

https://a2asimulations.com/forum/viewto ... d+trimotor


That's a great video. I like the way it's split into two parts - watching a flight from the ground, and then your trip. That's quite a scenic little airport too - where is it ?