Page 1 of 2

Personal Review of Payware Lancaster!!

Posted: 09 Apr 2015, 00:16
by Aharon
Shalom and greetings all my pals,

Okay okay here are screenshots and my personal opinion review of payware First Class Simulations Lancaster.

Installation was very easy and simple. There are two files. One model installation file dated 2012 contains installation of model and many liveries. The second file contains patch update dated 2010. I asked tech support of First Class Simulation if I could skip the update patch that has older date than the main installation file. I was surprised and pleased to receive the response from tech support within 24 hours via Facebook (24 hour due to time zone difference in different countries). They told me that I should install the patch regardless of the date because of automatic fail safe feature that will inform me automatically if the model base is already latest version and the patch is not necessary. So far, the patch installation went smooth too meaning it was necessary for my model.

The package comes with three manuals printed in PDF format. One explains history of the Lancaster. Second contains installation instructions. Third is the flying tutorial. The flying tutorial manual has SUPERB easy guide instructions on how to start engines with beautiful screenshot examples showing how to start engines to the point you would not need to go to YouTube to look for videos of instructions on how to start engines of Lancaster.

However, strange enough, the three manuals make no mention of minimum runway distance for both take off and landing, no mention for cruising altitude and speed at different load conditions, no mention of climb rate per minute, no mention of descent rate per minute, and no mention of pitot tube or deice settings as well as how to set auto altitude. Makes me wonder how I can fly at altitude level? You cannot expect me to use lame FSX default keyboard button command to hold altitude!!!

The panel is superb with plenty of gauges. Although reading gauges' numbers and indicator needles are easy and clear to see, the panel is too dark and hard to read. I cannot read words on the panel and to figure out what knobs, buttons, and switches are, I have to hover my mouse indicator to each knob, switch, or button so that bubble window would appear informing me the name of knob, switch, or button which means time consuming for me and not ideal for flying. I have no problem seeing words on panels of DC-4s, DC-6s, DC-7s, C-46s, and all other heavy propellers but this Lancaster panel is too dark for me. Use flashlight on the computer screen to read words on knobs, switches, or buttons would not work. I read in the manuals that First Class Simulation dim the brightness of the panel by 33 percent to enhance realism. I wish they had not done that.

However the details of the panel are superb and extremely realistic.

So the exterior appearance of Lancaster is too. Beautiful along with very realistic tires!!! The wings are superb and the propellers are very nice but the length of the body of the plane seems to be little short just like Captain Sims C-130 Hercules has too short body length. CalClassics DC-4, DC-6, and DC-7 have more realistic body length. Maybe Lancaster's body length is supposed to look short or not. That is up to all of you to judge.

Lancaster comes in only three window views for exterior of the plane which is disappointing BUT it does not take genuis or seasoned flight simmer to figure out how to add more window views to aircraft.cfg which I intend to do so because of my belief in beauty of screenshots.

Fortunately, the window views of virtual cockpit are superb and cover whole thing. I guess that First Class Simulations wants to make sure you have unlimited ability to look out for enemy interceptors from the pilot seat!!!

The model package comes in about 7 or 8 liveries each with different weapon loads. I wish they would include more famous liveries with many victory or mission decorations on the liveries for RAF. I am guessing there have to be more liveries somewhere on the internet to download.

However, I do not see on three manuals some instructions for function for opening or closing bomb bay doors. Although I would not expect for 20 buck price tag a nice feature or function for droppable ordinance but I think it should feature opening and closing of bomb bay doors.

Would I recommend First Class Simulations Lancaster? Of course yes. I just hope I or anybody can figure out how to modify panel.cfg to brighten the panel so that I can read words on the panel. Is it doable or is it out of question as it is for programming genuises?

Bear in the mind that my review of this plane is result of my ground testing of the plane. I have not yet conducted take off test, flying test, fuel consumption rate realism test, and landing test.

What is interesting is that when I conduct ground test of the Lancaster plane in normal window view looking around the plane, everything looks great but when I am in locked window view looking at the plane, the ground or apron or runway or where ever the plane's wheels are resting on shakes little bit as if there is FSX default earthquake. Just the ground shaking little bit but not trees or buildings.

Presenting screenshots of ground testing of Lancaster

Image

Image

Image

Image

Image

Image

Image

Image

Image

Image

Image

Image

Regards,

Aharon

Re: Personal Review of Payware Lancaster!!

Posted: 09 Apr 2015, 01:34
by DaveB
That's a nice review Aharon and thanks for posting it :thumbsup:

I don't have the FCS Lancaster installed at the moment but I'll make a point of reinstalling it tomorrow to check some of the points you mentioned. I don't ever recall it shaking on the deck (though of course.. the real one would). The panel brightness.. all UK aircraft of that era had black panels as I'm sure you'll know. I can't remember if this rendition is any darker than it should be so I'll look at that too. Bomb bay doors are traditionally the / key. Again.. I can't remember if this is coded as such on the Lancaster or if different coding was used requiring a lever to be pulled or a switch to be made. Something else I'll look at ;) I don't think any variant of Lancaster had an AP.. hand flying being the order of the day.
As for repaints.. if you can't find any at www.flightsim.com .. you'll almost certainly find some at Simouthouse.

Flying by the book..
I'm not sure if ANY FCS model could be flown by the book with any degree of accuracy. I have some Lancaster Pilots Notes here somewhere which I'll be happy to upload if you want them ;)

Glad you're reasonably pleased with it for now.. especially the price ;)
ATB
DaveB B)smk

Re: Personal Review of Payware Lancaster!!

Posted: 09 Apr 2015, 02:12
by Aharon
DaveB wrote:. I don't ever recall it shaking on the deck
Dave,

Glad you like my review. Thanks for your kind answers and kind offers. I look forward to your Lancaster notes that would be nice if you upload to your forums and make it permanent stick for any pilot for future references when they buy the payware copy.

I am referring to GROUND such as taxiway, apron, and runway as if there is earthquake. That was my view of the plane that is NOT from the deck or cockpit.



Regards,

Aharon

Re: Personal Review of Payware Lancaster!!

Posted: 09 Apr 2015, 16:53
by DaveB
Aharon..

I'm having difficulty locating the Lancaster Pilots Notes. It's here somewhere on an external drive.. I just have to find the right drive!!

Re the panel colour/lighting/legends.. I think a lot depends on your monitor temp. On my WinXP pc.. the panel looks fine. Some of the legends are a little difficult to read but this might be expected. Also.. the position of the sun will have an effect in FSX making the panel lighter or darker depending on where the sun is in relation to the panel.

I can't see any shaking no matter what view I choose. It's not unknown for models to shake on the ground a little at more extreme distances. Some jump off the ground :-O Didn't notice it with this model but that doesn't really prove anything. :)

ATB
DaveB B)smk

Re: Personal Review of Payware Lancaster!!

Posted: 09 Apr 2015, 17:59
by Aharon
Dave,

Thanks for your kind replies
DaveB wrote:I'm having difficulty locating the Lancaster Pilots Notes. It's here somewhere on an external drive.. I just have to find the right drive!!
Please take time and when you find the notes, it would be nice and gratefully appreciated if you post notes on the forum and make the permanent sticky post with title called Pilot Notes For Anyone Who Purchases FCS Lancaster.
DaveB wrote:Re the panel colour/lighting/legends.. I think a lot depends on your monitor temp. On my WinXP pc.. the panel looks fine. Some of the legends are a little difficult to read but this might be expected. Also.. the position of the sun will have an effect in FSX making the panel lighter or darker depending on where the sun is in relation to the panel.
Well my monitor is on full brightness mode and I did set FSX to midday or noon so that I would get full sunlight at the panel. That trick apparently did not work.
DaveB wrote:I can't see any shaking no matter what view I choose. It's not unknown for models to shake on the ground a little at more extreme distances. Some jump off the ground :-O Didn't notice it with this model but that doesn't really prove anything. :)
I think you misunderstood me. I did not say that the model shakes (besides wings are supposed to flex or shake little bit if the engines are on at full strength anyway for any plane). I said the ground under the plane whether it is taxiway, runway, passenger ground apron, cargo ground apron, or gate ground apron shakes little bit as if there is earthquake. The plane is not shaking and the trees as well as buildings are not shaking.

View the Lancaster (whole one) from ground level as if you are lying on ground and you will see the ground shakes little bit. If you sit on cockpit, look at ground and you will see ground shake little bit even with engines off.

Regards,

Aharon

Re: Personal Review of Payware Lancaster!!

Posted: 10 Apr 2015, 14:11
by Aharon
Just to let you know I have added more window views while eliminating FCS's window views and the results are amazing. Even the earthquake problem has stopped due to my addition of window views.

Will post screenshot results of addition of window views.

Regards,

Aharon

Re: Personal Review of Payware Lancaster!!

Posted: 11 Apr 2015, 10:54
by Nigel H-J
Hi Aharon, don't have the Lancaster but was very impressed with your review, very well written and look forward to reading further additions.

As far as the pilot notes go I wonder whether this site may help as these are the standard notes and logs used by RAF Bomber Crews during the war.

http://www.fiskertonairfield.org.uk/photo_2.html
and this:
http://www.lancaster-archive.com/lanc_main_page.htm

Good luck.

Nigel.

Re: Personal Review of Payware Lancaster!!

Posted: 11 Apr 2015, 14:44
by Aharon
Nigel,

Thanks for your kind comments and thanks for cool links. One of your links showed pilot log report that had checklist before take off and after landing. It said pitot tube cover remove checklist meaning that Lancaster had pitot deice but I cannot find button for that on my FCS Lancaster. Got to look for it again!!!

Also thanks for nice operating manual of Lancaster. Lots of info but cannot find climb rate for feet per minutes and cannot find minimum runway distance for take off and landing.

Regards,

Aharon

Re: Personal Review of Payware Lancaster!!

Posted: 11 Apr 2015, 20:37
by DaveB
Aharon..

Re Climb Rate.. you're making the same mistake as most simmers do (and I might add.. I have done in the past too) :) What is important during takeoff and climb is airspeed.. NOT rate of climb. You climb at a given airspeed depending on your weight and how fast you want to get to altitude. Many Pilots Notes for older aircraft (and probably new ones too) will quote a Rapid ascent and a Best ascent and to achieve these.. you fly at a specified airspeed taking what climb rate comes your way. This may be relatively high in the early stages of your climb (relatively speaking for a Lancaster) but will gradually fall away the higher you get. The important thing is that you maintain the prescribed airspeed. Hope this makes sense ;)

Anywho.. I've dug out yet another external drive and found the Lancaster Pilots Notes. These do not give information on runway length Vs weight.. I don't think any PN's give this sort of information. You need a full manual for that. PN's are just that.. quick reference notes for pilots. I've uploaded it HERE and will leave it here for a short time. I'll have to remove it as soon as I know you have it ;) It's in pdf format by the way :cpu:

ATB
DaveB B)smk

Re: Personal Review of Payware Lancaster!!

Posted: 11 Apr 2015, 20:56
by Aharon
Thanks, Dave for the PDF!!!

Meanwhile here are samples of my modification of addition of window views as seen below:

Image

Image

Image

Image

Image

Once again, Dave thanks for all your kind help

Regards,

Aharon