Marks out of 10 for this landing???
Moderators: Guru's, The Ministry
- Charlie Bravo
- Concorde

- Posts: 1109
- Joined: 27 Jun 2004, 12:03
- Location: STN/EGSS
Re: Marks out of 10 for this landing???
I was on shift that day and watched it on approach. There was a strong crosswind and several aircraft had already gone around.
The next aircraft to land was a Euromanx Dash 8 200 which got in with no problems and I believe he reported debris on the runway as the next inbound went around and a runway inspection was carried out.
I don't know what the crosswind limits on the RJ are but our Fokker 50's have a limit of 23kts at LCY and 33kts everywhere else. Quite a few of ours had already diverted.
The next aircraft to land was a Euromanx Dash 8 200 which got in with no problems and I believe he reported debris on the runway as the next inbound went around and a runway inspection was carried out.
I don't know what the crosswind limits on the RJ are but our Fokker 50's have a limit of 23kts at LCY and 33kts everywhere else. Quite a few of ours had already diverted.
A bird in the hand will probably sh!t on your wrist.
Re: Marks out of 10 for this landing???
Just hope none of the passengers aboard had haemorrhoids when they experienced that landing or rather should I say.....arrival? :o
Nigel.
Nigel.
I used to be an optimist but with age I am now a grumpy old pessimist.
Re: Marks out of 10 for this landing???
Hm, that must be the time a little old lady passenger asked the flight attendant ....
"Did we land, or were we shot down!?"
"Did we land, or were we shot down!?"
John
- Techy111
- Battle of Britain

- Posts: 3319
- Joined: 15 Aug 2007, 13:51
- Location: Coming out of Retirement.
Re: Marks out of 10 for this landing???
I have NEVER seen a landing like it....! ! ! Well maybe some RAF pilots....but thats another story....
What a tough little bird......
I grimaced the whole way through.....CB i bet you thought you was going to see a crash....?
Tony
What a tough little bird......
I grimaced the whole way through.....CB i bet you thought you was going to see a crash....?
Tony
The last surviving and complete Vickers Vanguard....."Superb"






- DaveG
- The Gurus
- Posts: 8091
- Joined: 23 Jun 2004, 18:05
- Location: in a deep, dark hole somewhere.
- Contact:
Re: Marks out of 10 for this landing???
Don't see what the problem is,
looks like any one of my landings 
Dave G.
-
Vulcan_to_the_Sky!
- Concorde

- Posts: 748
- Joined: 21 Apr 2006, 19:18
- Location: Lancashire, Red Rose County
- Contact:
Re: Marks out of 10 for this landing???
I'd give it about a -7!
Thats just about the worst real life landing I've ever seen that doesn't result in half the plane being left on the tarmac!
Thats just about the worst real life landing I've ever seen that doesn't result in half the plane being left on the tarmac!

- Techy111
- Battle of Britain

- Posts: 3319
- Joined: 15 Aug 2007, 13:51
- Location: Coming out of Retirement.
Re: Marks out of 10 for this landing???
Tonks....when i was at RAF Gatow a VC10 was "loaned" to a film crew for a sequence and we all went out on the apron to fully appreciate the beauty of the VC10 landing at Gatow....
Now this is a small field but did have the Britannia 737's landing there on trooping flights....
OK someone spotted her flying in on approach and everything looked ok right until the pilot actually tried to land.....
(Just checking tonks.....you didn't come to Gatow in 86 did you....?
)
Anyway.....the graceful old lady flared for what looked like a perfect touchdown but......thats when it all went screwy..... :o
The nose dropped , nosewheel hit first , bounced up , then nosewheel again then starboard main then port then full power and around she went.....gave us time to write our scorecards out and the pilot brought it around for a second go.....even worse than the first.....
By this time us groundcrew where rolling around on the tarmac holding onto our bladders.....can you picture that....?
He finally plonked it down on the 3rd try and we all stood there as he taxied in holding our scorecards up....Guess who got the blame...?
Yeah the poor old co-pilot....
That day i really thought i would see a crash of a BIG plane (seen loads of little ones crash) Oh that was a laugh......no disrespect Sir.... :roll:
SAC Techy111.........
Tony
Now this is a small field but did have the Britannia 737's landing there on trooping flights....
OK someone spotted her flying in on approach and everything looked ok right until the pilot actually tried to land.....
(Just checking tonks.....you didn't come to Gatow in 86 did you....?
Anyway.....the graceful old lady flared for what looked like a perfect touchdown but......thats when it all went screwy..... :o
The nose dropped , nosewheel hit first , bounced up , then nosewheel again then starboard main then port then full power and around she went.....gave us time to write our scorecards out and the pilot brought it around for a second go.....even worse than the first.....
By this time us groundcrew where rolling around on the tarmac holding onto our bladders.....can you picture that....?
He finally plonked it down on the 3rd try and we all stood there as he taxied in holding our scorecards up....Guess who got the blame...?
Yeah the poor old co-pilot....
That day i really thought i would see a crash of a BIG plane (seen loads of little ones crash) Oh that was a laugh......no disrespect Sir.... :roll:
SAC Techy111.........
Tony
The last surviving and complete Vickers Vanguard....."Superb"






Re: Marks out of 10 for this landing???
I suppose everyone has a bad day at the office sometime. Its just so happens this poor bugger was filmed by someone who was in the right place at the right time.We've all been there! ;-) 
Last edited by VEGAS on 14 Feb 2008, 09:13, edited 1 time in total.
I suffer from paranoid amnesia. I can't remember who I don't trust.- Chris Trott
- Vintage Pair

- Posts: 2592
- Joined: 26 Jun 2004, 05:16
- Location: Houston, Texas, USA
- Contact:
Re: Marks out of 10 for this landing???
They don't call me "jackrabbit" for nothing... 









